Monday, May 4, 2009

Consistency is the Key to Parenting

I need to consistently love my children.

I need to consistently give grace.

I need to consistently find new ways to encourage my children.

I need to consistently hold them to a higher standard.

I need to consistently be consistent in my parenting.

The one thing I need to stop being consistent about is my nagging.
It does no good.

In church the other day, Caleb and William were just awful. They focused on each other (in every negative way possible) instead of paying attention to the service. And I was sitting right next to them. And John and I had had our consistent "behave in church, we know you can do it" speech on the drive over. William kept looking at Caleb in the most irritating way and thought it would be cool if he could sneak a hand hold in when Caleb wasn't looking. This of course irritated Caleb (our germaphobe) who is quick to anger in a terrible way. Honestly, I spent a good part of the service trying to keep peace between the two.

"Stop it, you two," I whispered.
"William, don't look at your brother."
"Caleb, ignore him. Stop squeezing his hand."
"So help me, you will be grounded for a month."

Honestly, I was being an awful parent.... a nagging nelly....... and even though we got through the service, it was really an exhausting experience, one I didn't want to keep repeating.

In the car ride home, I told John about the specifics of their behavior. It is not like he didn't see the fidgeting going on between the three of us.

Caleb defended his behavior but I made it clear that he was the older one and that he was allowing William to be the puppetmaster. Caleb gave William the power to push his buttons--- and Caleb's anger and complete disgust with his brother only fueled William's desire to get some reaction albeit negative and painful. I told him how sad it was to me to not be able to remember a time where Caleb was nice or uplifting to his brother William. Caleb loves to have the last word about every single thing concerning William if it is a chance to put him down. Sure I could force good behavior from Caleb, but it was long overdue for Caleb to take responsibility for his mouth and break this awful cycle. I explained to Caleb how William is at an age right now where he needs not only encouraging words from his parents and other siblings-- but he especially needs some encouragement from an older brother who even though he might not show it-- really looks up to. I reminded him of how William had his own struggles and I asked Caleb the tough question, "What are you doing to be a positive person in William's life?"

William was his normal self during the discussion---- I could see an inappropriate "Mom, I don't understand what you are saying" look plastered on his face. It was frustrating to once again see the magnitude of William's inability to understand the breakdown of this relationship and what role he played in it.

Enough talking--- most of this they have all heard before.
No more nagging. Judge Mom lays down the sentence. Caleb and William forced to be in the same room together for a few hours----- next time they will be sleeping in the same bed if they so much as breathe on each other with the intent to bug. Enough was enough.

I took this opportunity to let the rest of the kids know that maximum consequences were going to be handed out from that point forward because my nagging was like "empty threats" to them. I rattled off a few fruits of the spirit and asked them to just treat each other the way they wanted to be treated.

Not ten minutes later Sveta comes into the kitchen as I am cooking lunch to tell me that Miss Anna wasn't going to let her throw a piece of trash in the girl's trash can.

So I yelled, "Anna!" (I know I'm really bad about this and need to work on it.)

"What is going on?"

She proceeded to sass defensively, "I'm tired of taking out the trash. Sveta never takes it out, so she can't use the trash can!"

"First off Anna, you need to turn your voice down and not talk to Mom that way. What do you mean you take out the trash all the time? You mean when you took the trash out this one morning because it was overflowing and I insisted you do it? You know that Caleb and Adam usually always take out the trash-- not you. And where would you have liked Sveta to put her trash? Under your pillow? In the dirty clothes hamper? Would that have been a better spot? Or do you see that using the trash can was actually a reasonable request?"

She still felt like arguing with me that she took out the trash all the time (BTW she is one of the top 3 messiest children in the family) and how Sveta is always mean to her, and Rachel always bosses her around, and Julia always puts stuff on her her bed, etc.

"Anna, just please go lay down in your bed. I told all of you that I am not going to entertain this behavior anymore without immediate consequences. Now-go-lay-down and I'll call you when lunch is ready."

Defiantly begging not to send her to bed she quickly began with her, "No.. No...No... don't send me to bed...... I will change.... I won't act like this anymore..."

"Anna, please go lay down right now if you don't want me to drag you there!" (There I go yelling again)

Feeling myself losing this parenting battle as I allowed my smallest and youngest daughter to pull my strings I reached out my hand and said, "Come on Anna, go lay down."

She continued defiantly until I grabbed her hand and marched her little self back to her bed.

Instead of willingly following me to her room, she instead pulled away as hard as she could.

Once in her room she started telling me how I had hurt her arm. Rachel and Annalyn who saw the whole thing, gave their sister the "oh brother" look and she snapped at them to.

"Anna if your arm hurts it is your own fault. Had you just followed me into your room-- better yet--- had you just listened to me when I asked you to go lay down---- even better yet--- had you just listened to my request to have a good day--- none of this would have happened."

Her arguing continued and in the end she ended up spending a good hour on her bed. I left her with the thought that if when she got up her behavior wasn't noticeably different and her heart was not repentant she would spend the rest of the day in her bed---- not a threat, but a promise.

Then it was lunch time.

And from that point on, we had one of the best behaved, everyone get-along Sundays that we had had in a long time.

Lord, help me to be consistent in your ways, and to die to self in my nagging, yelling, frustrated ways.

Micah 7:8 Though I fall, I will rise again. Though I sit in darkness, the Lord himself will be my light.

26 inspiring thoughts:

Anonymous said...

Wow your honesty and reality in your blog continues to amaze me, thank you for allowing us to follow your lives.
Thought this was interesting, disabilities are looked down upon all over the world
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=103725672

The Kaysers said...

Holy cow! I am exhausted after reading this. I can relate to that feeling and have to work REALLY hard on being consistent. I hate acting "mean", as my kids say, but I hate nagging and yelling at them even more. Good job, mom! Jen

Kathy C. said...

Whew. We have enough drama with four. I can't imagine with more.

Kristin said...

Sometimes I tell my kids (and myself) that it's my JOB to be mean. :) I wish I could always be consistent in being "mean" (following through with consequences) and cut out all the nagging/yelling that seems to creep in. Thanks for an honest post that I can relate to fully!

Mike and Christie said...

Ahhhhh kids.... gotta love em. :)

I have been known a time or two to get up and sit in between two kids to their horror that anybody might have seen they needed to be taught a lesson without words during a church service. :)

I think you are correct about consistency. That way they know exactly what expect. No surprises. :)
It is just hard sometimes when you are so tired, or there are so many, or the schedule is different. :)

You are a fab mom Christine. :)

Simply, Sarah said...

I think yesterday was a squirrelly day for children all over the nation! Or, at least here too.

It is so hard to be consistent, isn't it. I've found that Primary music (children's church music) playing in the background helps immensely on the Sabbath day. Not all the time, but the majority of the time, if I start playing the piano or put on a Primary cd, the children will chill out and even start singing along.

You made me smile though, with the "top 3 messiest children in the family." Not many families can make such a numerically accurate statement:)

Martha said...

Wow, can I relate to that! (although it's been a while...)
I found using the word "expect" got results fairly easily. "I EXPECT you to go to your room." "I EXPECT you to put that away." ... I don't know why it worked, but it did.

My favorite "parenting" book was "A Family of Value" by John Rosemond. It really helped me see where I could make some simple improvements without being overly psychological.

I'm glad the rest of your day went good!

Christi said...

I struggle with this as well. In my case, I believe I expect too much from the older boys, in regards to helping with the little people. While I believe that they learn much from the helping, it really is not their "job", so in reality I have absolutely no right to yell at them. Thanks for talking about this, it highlighted a problem I've been noticing in my own parenting.

Audrey said...

Great post. I am consistenly inconsistent in my consistency. :) I am going to work on that, I promise!

Kristen said...

There must be something in the air, becuaes I've been really convicted about my parenting, too. I need to stop nagging, reminding, etc. and just start up with the consequences again.

Melissa said...

We have had the "siblings bugging each other" problem at church also. But usually a stern look and the words, "do you need 30 minutes at home?" does the trick.

The 30 minutes at home means... When we get home you are not allowed to change out of your Sunday best and get something to eat until you sit (next to the other offender) on a bench with arms folded and silent for 30 minutes. If they talk or make noise or bug each other the timer starts over again. They must show me how to behave in church.

I usually only have to administer this punishment once every 6 months or so.

Queen B said...

I really need to work on this. It takes so much energy to be consistent. I'm glad your efforts paid off yesterday.

rita from georgia said...

my two (now with kids of their own) frequently used the church service to poke, make faces, mumble under their breath to each other, etc. they were in the 10-13 year old range. after many threats from me that it must stop, one sunday i was probably PMSing i grabbed both by the hand and we all three set the remainder of the service on the front row.

Renee said...

What an insightful post. I am always amazed at how much happier our children are after we discipline them. It's like they are subconciously rejoicing in the boundary we set.

I know too well how exhausting sibling conflicts can be on parents. I often wonder how grieved God must be when we fuss with each other.

Your Blog and humble spirit are a blessing.

deb said...

Bless you, Christine. I am sorry that Anna had a difficult day. Having said that, I am constantly amazed by you and your family.
I will pray that tomorrow will be better for both of you.

All the best-
Deb

Heather said...

It is so true that sometimes we just know that things need to get a little tougher. You are doing such a great job!

Linda said...

I can relate to your entire post. Being consistent is one of my greatest challenges. When I see my kids mirror my inconsistencies right back at me it sure is eye opening.

Kimberly said...

Thank you for sharing this story... It brought me encouragement. :)

Connie said...

I believe that, sometimes, kids are driven to be contrary. They need to see what they can get away with, they need to let loose a bad mood and inflict that orneriness on others. Like any adult I believe they sometimes feel grumpy and, while they may not intend to make someone else grumpy, they may crave a good argument.... sorta like wanting a good cry when you're sad, or a good giggle when you're feeling giddy.

Those times, I think mom or dad reacting by raising their voice and getting angry is the perfect response... when the kid gets out into the 'real world', amongst people who do not love them automatically... well, they need to know that poking, prodding, bugging, mean, contrary, and crabby behavior will very likely tick someone off badly - and who knows what reaction will come back on them? I mean, if mom, who adores them, is pushed to the gasket blowing stage, is it really a good idea to act this way in public? Not saying that, as a parent, we should not try to improve our behavior! But don't beat yourself up. I think you are filling a perfectly natural role in your childrens' development.. 'let's try this out on mom first'... and they aren't even aware of it!

I think that one thing that helps us through an argument, is after they, and I, have had a chance to think about things, I talk to them about why I raised my voice. I might ask them why they think I did so. Separate from what they did... they know what they did... but why I reacted, specifically... "I was tired and cranky". "It was because you kept doing the same thing over and over and over after being told not to.", or "I was surprised and afraid you were going to get hurt.", etc. And I apologize. Not for their punishment/time out or whatever - they earned it, they keep it. But for me not being in control of myself. They were wrong, so was I... but it's ok, we're only human(!), and we still love each other. Life is a never ending learning experience :)

soontobemomof9 said...

I often think my life would be easier if all the kids came with the exact same personalities and likes and dislikes etc. But where is the adventure in that? How does one learn to have compassion and the skills needed to compromise if everyone is exactly the same? No other environment on earth will ever provide as much teaching as that of being part of a family. Esp. a large and varied one!

I have been there, seems I am always there some days. I just keep trying, doing the best I can and praying to God to let me see that which I can't, and to know that which I don't, and to let His Spirit flow from me. Parenting isn't for sissies! :).

soontobemomof9 said...

OH... and we have a seating arrangement almost everywhere we go. LOL Might be weird, but it helps ... usually. :)

Priscilla said...

yup...sounds like a typical household with kids! (even when you only have 3)

Anonymous said...

You know, there seems to be a definite pattern with sibling strife, I think. In my own experiences with my brothers and sisters, I have found that it's often the siblings who spend the most time together that are the most likely to get on each others nerves. I've also learned that siblings are more likely to bug each other when they're bored. Obviously spending time with each other can't be avoided, but I think that it might help to try to relieve some of the boredom. Like, maybe have the whole family sit down and play a game or something once a week.

julie said...

Thanks so much for sharing this. I have had many a day like this with my kids. I really need to be better about the nagging and follow through also. It can be exhausting at times, cant it?

Have a blessed day,
Julie

Beth said...

I have been faced just recently with this issue of consistency. It is so hard but very worth it. I too can fall in the pattern of yelling. I know it's not good. Thanks for your honesty and encouragement.

Wendy said...

I had to laugh cause it sounded so much like ME..(yes I can be a nagging nelly and even a yelling yippsie!)

I use to make my older two spend time together if they fought or were ugly... If they were really irritating or if it was bad enough I would not only make them spend time together ALONE but I made them clean baseboards, chair railings etc together.(anything that needed team work) I would assign one to dust and the other to wipe with a wet rag.. next room switch! Other times I forced them to sit and stare at one another until they could say several nice things SINCERELY to or about each other! Sometimes I forced them to play a game together.

Now the two littlest ones seem to be testing my patience with nit picking one another!

OH THE DRAMA..

I should have kept my blog Saunders Saga instead of Saunders Gang! ;-)

LinkWithin

Blog Widget by LinkWithin